Ktsoeva S.G. “Descent into Hell” vs “The Legend of the Great Guest”: Christian Dogma in the Ethno-Religious System of the Ossetians |
The article is devoted to the analysis of the Christian interference into the original ethno-religious system of the Ossetians. V. Miller in his “Ossetian etudes” referred to B. Gatiev’s work where the legend about Barastyr is narrated. This ruler of the world of the dead at the request of the “great guest” released sinners from the hell and welcomed them to the paradise. V.Miller suggested that this legend reflects the Christian dogmatic tradition of the Descent of Jesus Christ into hell. He, however, did not develop this hypothesis, and, to some extent, the present study is a scientific verification of this hypothesis. The analysis of the plot allows us to state with certainty its Christian basis. The undertaken comparative study of the Ossetian legend and Christian dogma revealed both coincidences and discrepancies between the separate elements of the legend with the canonical gospel. This necessitated addressing the Old and New Testament apocrypha, which relate this event. The present analysis leaves little doubt about the accuracy of Millerʼs guess. The reference to non-canonical texts in the course of this study is also due to the meagerness of references to the Descent into hell. The analysis of the non-canonical Gospels in the course of the comparative study contributed to its significant objectification, as a result of which the article highlights the problem of apocryphal borrowings. Judging by the small number of publications, this problem is one of the least investigated in the Ossetian studies. In addition, the materials of the comparative study helped to identify the third, unexpected object of analysis – the Jewish elements in the religious pre-Easter ritual («sufæhæræn æхsæv») among Ossetians. This made it possible to extend the research beyond the actual worldview scope to the other field of the religious system – ethno-religious cult practice. Keywords: V. Miller, B. Gatiev, ethnic religion of Ossetians, Christianity, Descent of Jesus Christ into hell, “the legend of the great guest”, apocrypha. References: 1. Miller V.F. Otgoloski apokrifov v kavkazskikh narodnykh skazaniyakh [Echoes of apocrypha Caucasian popular legends]. Fol'klor narodov Severnogo Kavkaza. Teksty issledovaniya [Folklore of the peoples of the North Caucasus. The texts of the research]. Moscow, Nauka, 2008, pp. 949-955. 2. Abaev V.I. Nartovskii epos osetin [The Narts epos of the Ossetians].Tskhinvali, Iryston, 1982. 106 p. 3. Tuallagov A.A. Nartovskii Batraz i istoriya khristianstva u alan [Narts’ Batraz and the history of Christianity among Alans]. Problemy osetinskogo nartovskogo eposa [The problems of the Ossetian Narts epos].Vladikavkaz, North Ossetian State University, 2000, pp. 217-231. 4. Mamiev M.E. Obraz narta Batraza i stanovlenie alanskoi pravoslavnoi traditsii [The image of Nart Batraz and establishing Alanian orthodox tradition] [electronic resource]. URL: https://www.geopolitica.ru/article/obraz-narta-batraza-i-stanovlenie-alanskoy-pravoslavnoy-tradicii 5. Darchiev A.V. Batraz-muravei (ob odnom motive nartovskogo eposa) [Batraz in the image of the ant (about one Narts’ motive]. Izvestiya SOIGSI [Proceedings of the North Ossetian Institute for Humanitarian and Social Studies]. 2011, iss. 7(46), pp. 26-37. 6. Kanukova Z.V. Pravoslavie v formirovanii rossiiskoi gosudarstvennosti i obshcherossiiskoi identichnosti v Osetii (konets XVIII - nachalo XX v.)[Christian orthodox church and forming of the Russian statehood and Russian national identity in Ossetia (the end of the XVIII – the beginning of the XX c.)]. Izvestiya SOIGSI [Proceedings of the North Ossetian Institute for Humanitarian and Social Studies]. 2016, iss. 20(59), pp. 40-50. 7. Miller V.F. Osetinskie etyudy. [The Ossetian etudes]. Vladikavkaz, North Ossetian Institute for Humanitarian Studies 1992. 716 p. 8. Gatiev B. Sueveriya i predrassudki u osetin [The superstitions and prejudice of the Ossetians]. Periodicheskaya pechat' Kavkaza ob Osetii i osetinakh. [Periodicals of the Caucasus about Ossetia and the Ossetians]. Tskhinvali, Iryston, 1987, iss. III, pp. 149-215. 9. Soshestvie vo ad [The Descent into hell]. Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya [Orthodox Encyclopedia] [electronic resource]. URL: https://www. biblioteka3.ru 10. Mitropolit Ilarion (Alfeev). Khristos – pobeditel' ada. Tema soshestviya vo ad v vostochno-khristianskoi traditsii [Christ is the winner over the hell. The theme of the descent into hell in the Eastern Christian tradition]. St-Petersburg, 2001. 430 p. 11. Novyi Zavet. Deyaniya svyatykh apostolov [New Testament. Acts of the Holy Apostles]. 12. Novyi Zavet. Pervoe poslanie Petra [New Testament. The first message of Peter]. 13. Grigorii Palama, svyatitel' Gomilii [Grigorii Palama, the prelate of Gomilia]. Monreal', 1965. 608 p. 14. Vetkhii Zavet. Kniga proroka Isaii [Old Testament. The book of the prophet Isaiah]. 15. Khister D. Dennitsa – tsar' Vavilonskii [Lucifer is the king of Babylon] [electronic resource]. URL: https: // www.realdevil.info 16. Otkrovenie svyatogo Ioanna Bogoslova [The revelation of St. John theologian]. 17. Vetkhii Zavet. Kniga Iova [Old Testament. The book of Iov]. 18. Vetkhii Zavet. Psaltyr' [Old Testament. Psalter]. 19. Khadikova A.Kh. Etnicheskie obrazy i traditsionnye modeli povedeniya osetin [The ethnic images and the traditional behavioral patterns of the Ossetians]. Vladikavkaz, North Ossetian Institute for Humanitarian and Social Studies, 2015, 430 p. 20. Evangelie ot Petra (sokhranivshiisya otryvok) [The Gospel of Peter (surviving passage)]. Russkaya apokrificheskaya studiya [Russian apocryphal studio] [Web-site]. URL: https://apokrif. fullweb.ru 21. Evangelie ot Nikodima [The Gospel of Nicodemus]. Russkaya apokrificheskaya studiya [Russian apocryphal studio] [Web-site]. URL: https://apokrif. fullweb.ru 22. Evsevii Aleksandriiskii. Slovo o soshestvii Ioanna Krestitelya vo ad [Word about the descent of John the Baptist into hell]. Russkaya apokrificheskaya studiya.[Russian apocryphal studio] [Web-site]. URL: https://apokrif. fullweb.ru 23. Otkrovenie svyatogo apostola Pavla [Relevation of the holy apostle Paul]. Apokrif. St. 33-44. Russkaya apokrificheskaya studiya [Russian apocryphal studio] [Web-site]. URL: https://apokrif. fullweb.ru 24. Zheltov M.S., Tkachenko A.A. Velikaya subbota. [The great Saturday]. Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya [Orthodox Encyclopedia]. Moscow, The Church and Science Center “Pravoslavnaya entsiklopediya”, 2004, vol. VII, pp. 431-443. 25. Kanukov A. Godovye prazdniki osetin. 3. Paskha.[The annual holidays of the Ossetians.3. Easter]. Terskie vedomosti [Terskie vedomosti]. 1892, no. 80. 26. Tuallagov A.A. K istorii iudaizma na Severnom Kavkaze (II). [To the history of Judaism in the North Caucasus]. Izvestiya SOIGSI. Shkola molodykh uchenykh [Proceedings of the North Ossetian Institute for Humanitarian and Social Studies. School of Young Scientists]. 2010, iss. 3, pp. 3-9. 27. Darchiev A.V. Osetinskie legendy o Ruimone: proiskhozhdenie i mifologicheskaya osnova [The Ossetian legends about Ruymon: the origin and mythological basis]. Istoricheskie, filosofskie, politicheskie i yuridicheskie nauki, kul'turologiya i iskusstvovedenie. Voprosy teorii i praktiki. [The historical, philosophical, political and legal sciences: theory and practice]. 2015, no. 6 (56), part I, pp. 57-62. |